Is the Myrtle Beach Short-Term Rental Market Dead—or Has the Game Changed?
Is the Myrtle Beach Short-Term Rental Market Dead—or Has the Game Changed?
By Kevin Gunn | Empire Elite Properties
If you own a Myrtle Beach vacation rental—or you’re considering buying one—you’ve probably heard some version of this question:
“Is the short-term rental market dead?”
Some owners are disappointed with their income. Buyers are questioning rental projections. A property that once seemed like an easy investment may now require more attention and a closer look at expenses.
My answer? I don’t believe the market is dead. But I do believe the assumptions that helped sell properties during the pandemic buying surge deserve a serious reset.
As someone involved in both coastal real estate sales and vacation rental management, I look at these properties from two perspectives: what makes someone want to buy them, and what makes a guest choose to stay in them.
Those are related questions, but they aren’t the same.
How did we get here?
The pandemic helped fuel a national rush toward vacation-home ownership. According to the National Association of REALTORS®, vacation-home sales increased 16.4% in 2020, compared with 5.6% growth in total existing-home sales. That is national context, rather than a measure of Myrtle Beach rental performance, but it illustrates the strength of the buying surge.
In my view, part of what we’re dealing with today is the aftermath of that period: purchase decisions and income expectations formed under unusual circumstances.
A strong rental year can make an investment look straightforward. The problem comes when that year becomes the permanent assumption behind the purchase.
A property needs to make sense under realistic conditions—not only when everything goes right.
That means reviewing recent performance, understanding the expenses, and asking how the investment would hold up if income falls short or repairs cost more than expected.
Myrtle Beach isn’t one rental market
Two condos a mile apart can have very different rental appeal. Even two units in the same building can produce different results.
Location matters, but so do amenities, parking, elevator access, common-area upkeep, and the experience guests have getting into the property.
A building with features that attract families may compete differently from one that appeals to couples, golf groups, or longer-stay guests. Access restrictions can also affect what an outside rental manager can offer.
Before buying, ask:
- Which amenities can my guests actually use?
- What rental and management restrictions apply?
- How well are the common areas maintained?
- What reasons would guests have to book outside summer?
You own an individual condo, but your guests experience the whole building.
Your unit still needs a reason to be chosen
When guests see several similar condos in the same resort, they compare photos, reviews, sleeping arrangements, amenities, and total price.
If your unit looks interchangeable with everything around it, price can become the easiest way to compete.
That doesn’t mean every property needs an expensive renovation. Sometimes fresh paint, coordinated bedding, better lighting, comfortable furniture, and stronger photography can improve its presentation.
The goal is to make the property appealing and accurately represented. Improvements should have a purpose—not simply add expense.
Guests shop the total price
Owners often focus on the nightly rate. Guests ultimately decide whether the entire stay is worth the cost.
Cleaning charges and other mandatory fees can make a short reservation substantially more expensive. That is especially important for studios and one-bedroom condos competing for shorter stays.
Lowering the nightly rate may help generate a booking, but it can also reduce the owner’s accommodation revenue while leaving the other fees unchanged.
Sometimes the question isn’t whether the nightly rate is too high. It’s whether the overall pricing structure makes sense.
Fees should cover legitimate costs, but they also need to be evaluated alongside booking conversion, stay length, and owner profitability.
Rental revenue isn’t owner profit
A rental projection is a starting point. It isn’t a cash-flow analysis.
Buyers should understand exactly what an income figure includes. Is it accommodation revenue? Does it include cleaning fees or taxes? Is it actual historical income or a forecast? How much personal use does it assume?
Then consider the ownership expenses:
- HOA dues and potential assessments
- Property taxes and insurance
- Management and applicable booking costs
- Utilities not included in the HOA
- Repairs, furnishings, and replacement reserves
- Mortgage payments, when financed
A condo can generate bookings and still fail to meet an owner’s financial goals.
A lower purchase price can improve the equation, but it doesn’t erase building issues, rental restrictions, or operating costs.
Management needs ongoing attention
Publishing a listing is the beginning of the work.
Effective management involves monitoring booking activity, reviewing rates and minimum stays, maintaining listing accuracy, coordinating property care, and learning from guest feedback.
Technology helps identify patterns and opportunities. Local judgment helps determine what to do with them.
An automatic discount isn’t always the right answer. Neither is holding a rate simply because the property achieved it in a previous year.
The strategy should reflect the property, season, booking window, and guest—not just a default setting.
So, is the market dead?
My view is that there are still opportunities, but they require more careful evaluation than an attractive photo and an optimistic income projection.
For buyers, that means selecting the property and building carefully, verifying financing options, and budgeting realistically.
For existing owners, it means reviewing the entire operation: presentation, guest pricing, expenses, property condition, and management strategy.
Sometimes the answer is an adjustment. Sometimes it’s an improvement. And sometimes an honest review shows that the property no longer fits the owner’s goals.
The question I’d ask is: “Does this specific property make sense at this price, with these expenses, under a realistic operating plan?”
That is a much more useful conversation than declaring the entire market dead—or promising that every beach condo is a great investment.
Considering a Myrtle Beach condo, or wondering why your current rental isn’t meeting expectations?
Let’s review the building, the numbers, and your goals together.
Kevin Gunn | Empire Elite Properties
Buying or selling: kevin@empireeliteproperties.com
Property management: info@empireeliteproperties.com
Rental performance varies by property. Historical income and projections do not guarantee future results.
Categories
Recent Posts




